Location of Lucy Bagby's Arrest ID: 6455 | This file appears in: The Arrest and Trial of Lucy Bagby The arrow on this 1874 map of Cleveland's first ward highlights the location of Lucius A. Benton's residence, site of Lucy Bagby's dramatic arrest on January 19, 1861. The eight-story Columbia Building later stood on this site until it too was demolished for a casino parking lot. | Date: 1874 | Source: Cleveland Public Library Digital Gallery Atlases, Maps, and Park Plans of Cleveland and Cuyahoga County Download Original File SourceCleveland Public Library Digital Gallery Atlases, Maps, and Park Plans of Cleveland and Cuyahoga CountyDate1874 "Location of Lucy Bagby's Arrest" appears in: The Arrest and Trial of Lucy Bagby